Order by Wednesday, Dec 18 to arrive before Christmas. Shipping will resume Monday, Jan 6 📦

FREE Local Pick up in Bethlehem, PA weekdays through Monday, Dec 22! We will reopen Monday, Jan 6. Select 'Pick-Up' at checkout. 🎄

FREE STANDARD SHIPPING on orders $50 or more in Zone 1! See Shipping for details

BEST SELLERS

The favorites of our staff and customers!

27 products

Sort

Sold Out

7 Year Aged White Cheddar

Sold Out

7 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar

7 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar cheese

7 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar

Asiago w/ Rosemary

Cheddar Cheese Bacon Burger

BellaVitano Espresso

BellaVitano Merlot

BellaVitano Tennessee Whiskey

Blue Cheese Cheddar

Blueberry Infused Cheddar Cheese

Blueberry Infused Cheddar

Cheese Curds - White Garlic & Dill

Cheese Curds - Plain White

Cheese Curds Poutine

Cheese Curds - White Plain

Sale

$16.00 $8.00 Save $8.00

Chipotle Cheddar Cheese

Chipotle Cheddar

Chipotle Cheddar

Sold Out

Cinnamon Apple Cheddar

Garlic & Herb Cheese Spread

Garlic & Herb Cheese Spread

Sold Out

Garlic & Herb Jack

Sold Out

Ghost Pepper Jack Cheese

Ghost Pepper Jack

$12.00 from $11.00 Save $1.00

Horseradish Havarti

Havarti Spicy Peach Super Sandwich

Horseradish Havarti

Sold Out

Port Wine Cheese Spread

Port Wine Cheese Spread

Smoked Gouda

Gouda Breakfast

Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

Spinach and Artichoke Jack Cheese

Spinach and Artichoke Jack

Insulated Cooler

Keystone Farms Cheese E-Gift Card

Sold Out

Cheese Curds - Maple Bacon

Gift Box Add-on

BEST SELLERS